Joy Chen, executive director of the Every Fire Survivor’s Network, condemned the lack of transparency surrounding the proposal, noting the administration has failed to produce financial analysis justifying the alleged emergency. While the state’s Wildfire Fund maintains a $38 billion payment capacity against estimated claims of $10 billion to $15 billion, critics contend the governor is pushing to redirect compensation funds toward utility shareholders without public oversight.

Legislators are also facing heat over proposed "bright line" boundaries that would arbitrarily disqualify survivors from compensation based on their proximity to a fire perimeter. Survivors like Chen argue these lines ignore the reality of smoke damage and trauma. Senator Sasha Renee Perez joined the rally, urging the legislature to refocus on utility accountability rather than corporate liability. With major utilities like PG&E, Edison, and Sempra reporting over $10 billion in recent profits and massive executive payouts, advocates are calling for a complete halt to dividends until all victims are made whole.