Former California Public Utilities Commission President Loretta Lynch spearheads the critique, specifically targeting a recent video statement from PG&E CEO Patti Poppe. Poppe claimed the utility lacks the capital to build new safety equipment without additional borrowing and rate hikes. Lynch dismissed this as a fabrication, noting that ratepayers have already funded these projects through existing rate hikes that include a 10% profit markup and tax coverage.

Consumer Watchdog has filed a formal petition with the PUC, demanding an order to show cause for why the utility is withholding funds already collected from customers. Lynch argues that PG&E is leveraging its monopoly position to secure a legal shield against liability for its own operational failures. The group is now calling for a comprehensive audit of the company’s finances to determine where these collected funds are being directed if they are not being used for their intended infrastructure purposes.